simbrian's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[After Lord Of The Rings]

meh..

Animation was passable, but I liked the music so I let what you have play through to the end.

Interesting idea though, to make up your own story after LOTR. Firstly, I think it's unlikely that the *ex*-ringbearer would go across the sea. Pippin didn't die, and neither did the elf king, unless you skipped over some battles that took place between the end of the LOTR and the start of your story.

umairnadeem responds:

well, if you have read the book and look at the appendencies, you'll notice that it says "TRADITION IS NOW HANDED DOWN THAT MASTER SAMWISE HAD PASSED THE GREAT TOWERS AND OVER THE GREAT SEA." and... merry and pippin DID die, with King Elessar, and then Arwen Arianna went to the great forests of lorien, (now abandoned and lonely) and Arwen lay there in grief and died. I've studied quite alot of the appendix and this is what i have evidently found. Samwise, the Ring-Bearer, is now in Valinor, the Undying Lands, as well as Legolas AND GILMI!

[Madness Killing Test 1]

it's alright

I got the feeling of a badly-filmed movie when I watched this. The animations moved a bit fast, but otherwise looked very nice. I'd suggest changing the perspective to a little farther back, and not moving the camera.

Cool music too. It fits well.

[Smiley -Battle for Smokes]

good stuff

That was awesome. A few parts, such as the blood splatters, could have been drawn better, but overall it was excellent.

[Le Click - Call Me Nikvid]

flashback...

Wow, this is bringing me way back in time... not the movie or the song, but the program. I remember playing with 3D movie maker on my VERY FIRST computer back in the 90's.

Taking into account how old that technology is, this is pretty darn good. You negative reviewers need to remember to view things from the proper perspective.

Good job man.

SamuraiClinton responds:

It wasn't on our very first computer though. Because our very first computer could only run Windows 3.1.

Therefore, I am probably older than you are here!

[AMIG0]

beautiful

but a sad cycle at the same time. This is VERY well done. Good job.

[kung fu chan]

good

that was pretty cool to watch, good job!

[Drip Jazz Redux]

good!

Beautiful animations + cool music = VERY good job!

[Power Level Over 9000]

good

It's been done before, and yours is a good one. Funny.

[Hand in My Pocket]

VERY good!

Beautiful animations, alright song. The lips were perfect. Please, continue your work!

[this is Madness: ep 1]

well

I suppose it wasn't bad. Cool music, it fit very well.

Zorexis responds:

well, it was pretty crap