simbrian's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Xeno Tactic 2]

I expected improvements in the sequel

First of all, i'd like to point out that this game is almost identical to Canyon Defense, which is pretty good.

I'll help you out, just in case you decie to brave a third (it can be the same as the second, with the following improvements):

-More money
-Less expensive upgrades please
-Flying enemies go across horizontally
-A little more advance warning of what's coming next, and with details like HP. The number of enemies doesn't really mean much.

and that's about it. A good try.

[GemCraft]

top TD on NG!

Easily the best TD i've ever played. I love everything about it.

It looks nice and allows for lots of flexibility and creativity in your gameplay style.

Only a few small problems that I noticed: Splash damage isn't even noticeable, and the gem bombs (the high level ones) seem underpowered.

Awesome work. You're my hero.

[Chaotic - Perim Protector]

good TD game

slow effect isn't noticeable, upgrades are too expensive, and it does get a little bit repetitive.

Fix those few things, add a little enemy variety, maybe some new maps, and you've good a good, solid game here.

I also couldn't get past level 27.

[Amazda_26th June]

not bad

Nice relaxing music, but it was a little tricky getting my cube into some of the gaps. Perhaps you could make it a circle isntead?

Also the solution was a little too easy.

stammersa1 responds:

using a circle would make no difference, but the hitTest's can be dodgy sumtime, i'll try to make it less buggy, but there is a restart button

I will also try to make it harder

[Warfare Transporter]

fun

Managed to hit myself more than the enemy did. i'd use keyboard controls with buttons for attacking air or water, to make it a little easier.

[Galactic Conquests]

a few issues

Lagging, difficulty selecting different towers, and some sort of bug which prevented me from taking any damage.

But still a very good try!

[MIRC]

awesome concept

A cool update would be to make the cubes a little bouncy on their own, because it was a pain to get them off of the floor, but otherwise it was fantastic!

[Besieged]

good

Nice looking, catchy music, and challenging gameplay.

I'd say it was a little difficult, and not very special. I've seen most of it before but nonetheless it is still a good TD game.

Fix the balancing issues, give the towers special abilities when they level up, add mroe towers, and you've got a winner.

It takes work to get to the top. Please keep up the good work!

[Master of Security]

good

I've played a few others very similar to this, the closest match being Desktop Defense.

A great game, but it does get boring quickly. I stopped after about level 30. The msot annoying are the guys that shoot at your towers, forcing you to upgrade the front row before anything else. I imagine later in the game those shooting guys would make quite a dent in your defenses.

Overall very good, but lack of variety lost you that one point. A few more upgrade options would have been nice as well.

[A One Level Game]

cool concept..

...but almost impossible without memorizing the steps, or incredible reflexes.

if you want it to be a playable game, slow it down.

I like the song too.