simbrian's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[After Lord Of The Rings]

meh..

Animation was passable, but I liked the music so I let what you have play through to the end.

Interesting idea though, to make up your own story after LOTR. Firstly, I think it's unlikely that the *ex*-ringbearer would go across the sea. Pippin didn't die, and neither did the elf king, unless you skipped over some battles that took place between the end of the LOTR and the start of your story.

umairnadeem responds:

well, if you have read the book and look at the appendencies, you'll notice that it says "TRADITION IS NOW HANDED DOWN THAT MASTER SAMWISE HAD PASSED THE GREAT TOWERS AND OVER THE GREAT SEA." and... merry and pippin DID die, with King Elessar, and then Arwen Arianna went to the great forests of lorien, (now abandoned and lonely) and Arwen lay there in grief and died. I've studied quite alot of the appendix and this is what i have evidently found. Samwise, the Ring-Bearer, is now in Valinor, the Undying Lands, as well as Legolas AND GILMI!

[Le Click - Call Me Nikvid]

flashback...

Wow, this is bringing me way back in time... not the movie or the song, but the program. I remember playing with 3D movie maker on my VERY FIRST computer back in the 90's.

Taking into account how old that technology is, this is pretty darn good. You negative reviewers need to remember to view things from the proper perspective.

Good job man.

SamuraiClinton responds:

It wasn't on our very first computer though. Because our very first computer could only run Windows 3.1.

Therefore, I am probably older than you are here!

[this is Madness: ep 1]

well

I suppose it wasn't bad. Cool music, it fit very well.

Zorexis responds:

well, it was pretty crap

[Random transformation!]

well

It was interesting, and the animation was passable. This type of thing is best when there's some kind of story or purpose to what's happening seemingly randomly.

Enlightener57 responds:

Ive been getting that a lot, next time there will be a storyline

[Max The Bee]

Wow..

For 80kb, I was expecting a spam submission, but that was pretty darn funny!

Might want to work on fixing that little pause when it finished the loop.

Good job!

Maxaroni5 responds:

i really tried to get rid of that, but its kinda hard to do, if i let the song pause the animation flows but if the song flows then the animation chops up.

[T. TotallyBS, Lucky Star!]

george

Well I didn't understand the content, but i'll rate it on the animation: In my opinion, everything was beautiful, especially the little smoke effects. Voices were also stunningly perfect.

Good job.

omegafinal responds:

It's meant to be a "Welcoming Video" for the RIT Anime Club, and some of the references are tailored towards them. You may read the Director's Notes for more info.

[Knuckles vs Shadow X]

76 parts?

Well it was short, and moderately confusing. How about making them 10X as long and only having 8 parts? That would be a much better idea IMHO.

Nose-army responds:

IMHO? Laugh my head off?
Nah, I'm only gonna make this and maybe a longer sequel where I get my friend to do a couple of parts.

[The Story of Voss Eps1]

not bad

It seems to be a pretty good start. Keep it up.

mightclark responds:

Thx ^_^

[The AIDS Collab II]

well...

I was only listening to this one, and I like the song. Ripped from Family Guy, correct?

I also like how you took that little theme thing from Donkey Kong, good memories.

Work on the buttons - we don't like clickong on text.

Caecilius responds:

Yes, its from family guy. About the buttons... yeah we got a little lazy. We'll fix it on the AIDS Collab III.